Did You Get the Market Direction Right but Still Fail to Make Money? It Might Be That You Didn't Choose the Right Strike Price

Image Source: pexels

Many investors in options trading find that even though their directional judgment was correct, they did not achieve the expected returns. This situation occurs frequently and is puzzling. The problem may lie in choosing the wrong strike price. Correctly understanding strike price selection is crucial for profitability. Investors should focus on pricing methods and risk control to improve trading performance.

Key Points

• Choosing the right strike price is crucial. A wrong strike price can leave options out-of-the-money, exposing investors to total loss risk.
• Time value decay affects option prices. Investors should pay attention to theta decay, especially for short-term options, to avoid losing significant value before expiration.
• Changes in implied volatility amplify option price swings. Investors need to consider market expectations and choose strike prices wisely to reduce risk.
• Assess risk tolerance when choosing strike prices. High-risk investors may choose OTM options, while low-risk investors should choose ITM or ATM options.
• Use combination strategies to diversify risk. Through vertical spreads, calendar spreads, etc., investors can balance risk and return, enhancing overall portfolio stability.

Common Reasons for Wrong Strike Price

In options trading, about 90% of loss cases are closely related to wrong strike price selection. Strike price directly impacts intrinsic value, time value, and implied volatility changes. Many investors judge market direction correctly but still fail to profit because of improper strike price choice. Below are three common reasons.

Insufficient Intrinsic Value

Intrinsic value is the core of an option. If investors pick the wrong strike price, the option may be out-of-the-money (OTM), leading to total loss at expiration. In the U.S. market, when buying calls, if the strike price is above the underlying asset price, the option has no intrinsic value. When buying puts, if the underlying price is above the strike, it also has no intrinsic value. Leverage magnifies both gains and losses—OTM options can result in losing all principal.

The wrong strike price can put an option OTM, exposing investors to 100% loss.

Time Value Decay

Time value is an important part of option pricing. If investors ignore time decay (Theta), they may lose significant value before expiration. In the U.S. market, short-term options decay faster, especially OTM options. Holding short-term OTM options accelerates capital loss. Strategies like calendar spreads or vertical spreads also become harder to manage if strike prices are chosen poorly.

• Time decay affects all strategies, but wrong strikes make it worse.
• Short-term options risk early assignment, increasing exposure in spread trades.
• Market moves turning OTM into ITM can amplify net time decay losses.

Implied Volatility Changes

Implied volatility reflects market expectations of future price swings. If investors ignore volatility shifts when picking strike prices, option prices may swing sharply, affecting returns. In the U.S., buyers pay higher premiums when implied volatility rises, increasing costs. Sellers collect higher premiums but face greater exercise risk. With the wrong strike, volatility changes worsen losses.

• Buyers pay more, taking more risk.
• Sellers earn more, but exercise probability rises.
• Implied volatility changes amplify price swings and hurt results.

Investors must recognize the risks of wrong strike prices and weigh intrinsic value, time decay, and implied volatility to choose scientifically.

Trading Direction and Strike Price

Image Source: pexels

Buying Calls

In the U.S., call buyers expect prices to rise. When picking strikes, they must balance cost and profit potential. Lower strikes cost more but carry higher intrinsic value and win probability. Higher strikes are cheaper but need bigger moves. Many investors pick the wrong strike, so even if direction is right, they don’t profit.

Example: A call with USD 100 strike—if the underlying is USD 102 at expiration, after costs the trade may still lose.

Buying Puts

Put buyers expect declines. Higher strikes are more expensive but more profitable if prices fall. Lower strikes are cheaper but need large drops to profit. Ignoring strike vs. volatility often results in being right on direction but not profiting.

Example: A put with USD 50 strike—if the underlying falls only to USD 48, after cost there may be no net profit.

Selling Options

Sellers mainly earn premiums. Strike selection must consider exercise risk. Higher call strikes bring lower premium but less exercise risk. Lower put strikes also lower premiums but reduce risk. Wrong strikes may lead to big losses.

Selling requires aligning strike selection with trend and risk tolerance.

Market Environment and Strike Price

Support and Resistance

In the U.S., traders often watch support and resistance when analyzing options. Support is a level where buying emerges; resistance is where selling appears. Strikes near these levels improve probability.

• Calls near support → higher win chance.
• Puts near resistance → more downside room.
• These levels guide better strike choices.

Support and resistance are crucial in options. Calls ideally near support; puts near resistance.

Market Expectation Analysis

Sentiment and expectations shape strike choices. U.S. traders often analyze option sentiment indices.

• Research shows investor sentiment correlates with option prices.
• Options are sensitive to sentiment. Bullish mood can lift premiums fast.
• PCA and other indices help traders refine strike selection.

For example, studies of SSE 50ETF options found sentiment boosts call premiums. While that’s China, U.S. markets show similar effects.

Avoiding Wrong Strike Price

Risk Tolerance Assessment

Strike choice starts with risk tolerance. High-risk investors may use OTM (cheaper but riskier). Low-risk investors should use ITM or ATM (higher intrinsic, safer). Beginners often lose principal picking OTM. Experienced traders diversify positions to limit single-contract risk.

Always predefine max loss per trade to protect the portfolio.

Matching Investment Goals

Goals also shape strike choice. For high short-term gains, OTM with leverage may fit, but expect losses. For steady growth, ITM or ATM is better. Beginners should start simple; advanced traders can try spreads like butterflies.

Risk Control

Image Source: pexels

Strike and Risk Management

In options, risk management is key. Strike price directly impacts profit potential and risk exposure. Many lose money despite correct direction due to wrong strikes. Investors often manage this by:

• Picking strikes near current market price for better liquidity and lower risk.
• In volatile times, prefer ATM or slightly ITM for balance.
• Adjust position sizing to avoid single-contract blowups.

Smart strike choice is central to risk management. Adjust with market conditions.

Combination Strategies

Single contracts are risky. Many use spreads to diversify. Examples:

• Vertical spreads: Buy one strike, sell another. Cuts cost, limits loss.
• Calendar spreads: Buy and sell same strike, different expiry. Arbitrage time value.
• Butterflies: Multi-strike setup with limited risk/reward.

Strike choice decides profit probability.

Avoiding wrong strikes requires:

• System over psychology
• Understanding biases
• Flexibly adjusting strikes with sentiment and volatility

FAQ

Can wrong strike choice be fixed?

Yes. Adjust by closing and reopening, or hedging with spreads. Timely adjustments cut risk.

How to judge a reasonable strike?

Consider underlying price, volatility, and risk tolerance. Reasonable strikes are near current price.

• Strikes near spot → higher win rate.
• Historical vol helps refine.

What strikes suit beginners?

ATM or slightly ITM. Safer with higher intrinsic value. Avoid deep OTM to protect capital.

How does strike affect spreads?

Strikes define spread risk/reward. Proper combos raise win chance. Adjust with market.

Does strike relate to expiry?

Yes. Short-term → more theta risk → pick ATM for safety. Long-term → OTM works for leverage.

• Shorter time = higher risk.
• Always weigh strike with expiry.

Selecting the right strike price is critical for profitable options trading, but challenges like high cross-border remittance fees, exchange rate volatility, and platform complexities can increase costs or reduce efficiency, impacting your options strategy execution.

BiyaPay offers a seamless financial platform to overcome these obstacles. Our real-time exchange rate queries provide instant access to fiat and digital currency conversion rates across various currencies, ensuring transparency and efficiency. With remittance fees as low as 0.5%, covering most countries globally and enabling same-day transfers, BiyaPay supports your options trading with swift fund access. Plus, you can trade US and Hong Kong stocks via our stocks feature without needing an overseas account, leveraging precise strike price selection to optimize strategy performance. Sign up with BiyaPay today to enhance your trading efficiency, seize options opportunities, and achieve steady wealth growth!