Say Goodbye to Stock Picking Worries: Understand the 5 Best High-Dividend US Stock ETFs in One Article

Image Source: unsplash

Are you eager to build a stable passive income cash flow? This article carefully selects and deeply analyzes five top high-dividend ETFs for you. You no longer need to painstakingly research individual stocks; these products allow you to easily hold a basket of high-quality dividend-paying companies, making them an ideal choice for steady investors.

We will delve into the following five highly regarded US stock ETFs: SCHD, VYM, JEPI, DGRO, DIVO

Key Takeaways

• High-dividend ETFs provide stable income, diversify investment risks, and offer potential for capital appreciation.
• When selecting high-dividend ETFs, consider dividend quality, expense ratio, investment strategy, and asset size.
• SCHD and VYM are suitable for investors seeking stability and low costs.
• JEPI and DIVO provide high monthly cash flow but may sacrifice share price upside potential.
• DGRO is suitable for long-term investors, focusing on companies with sustained dividend growth.

Beginner’s Guide to High-Dividend ETFs

Image Source: unsplash

Before diving into specific products, you need to grasp some foundational knowledge. This will help you determine if high-dividend ETFs align with your investment goals.

Core Concepts and Investment Advantages

A high-dividend ETF is a fund that aggregates multiple stocks with stable dividend payouts. By purchasing one ETF share, you indirectly own stocks in dozens or even hundreds of companies. Its core advantages are very clear:

• Stable Income Stream: High-dividend ETFs provide you with ongoing cash dividends, making them an excellent tool for building passive income.
• Effective Risk Diversification: You no longer need to bet on a single company; the diversified holdings of an ETF can significantly reduce the risk of individual stock blowups.
• Considerable Total Returns: In addition to dividends, high-quality companies’ share prices themselves have growth potential. This means you have the opportunity to gain both dividend income and capital appreciation.

Difference from Broad Market ETFs Unlike VTI or VOO that track the entire market, high-dividend ETFs focus more on screening companies that generate cash flow. You can think of it as the “cash cow” in your investment portfolio, specifically responsible for generating income.

Suitable Investor Profiles

So, are you suitable for investing in high-dividend ETFs? These investments are essentially lower risk, as companies that regularly pay dividends typically have stable financial conditions. If you match the following characteristics, high-dividend ETFs may be very suitable for you:

• Seeking stable cash flow to cover daily expenses.
• Preferring lower-risk investment strategies.
• Approaching or already in retirement, needing to convert assets into reliable income sources.

Screening Criteria for Quality ETFs

There are numerous high-dividend US stock ETFs on the market, and learning to screen them is key. You can focus on the following four metrics:

1. Dividend Quality: High yield does not equal high quality. You need to focus on dividend sustainability. For example, some indices require component stocks to have a dividend payout ratio no higher than 60%, or stable or growing dividends for 10 consecutive years, to ensure dividends are not “one-time” surprises.
2. Expense Ratio: This is the annual management fee you pay to the fund company. The lower the expense ratio, the more returns you retain.
3. Investment Strategy: Different ETFs have different stock selection logics. Some focus on value stocks, some on dividend growth, and others (like JEPI) use options strategies to enhance yields.
4. Assets Under Management (AUM): Larger-scale ETFs typically have better liquidity, easier buying and selling, and reflect market recognition.

In-Depth Analysis of 5 High-Dividend US Stock ETFs

Image Source: pexels

Now that you have mastered the basics, let’s dive into these five highly favored high-dividend ETFs on the market and see which one best fits your investment blueprint.

SCHD: The Gold Standard for Dividend Quality

If what you pursue is not just high dividends but the “quality” and “growth” of dividends, then SCHD is undoubtedly the gold standard in the market. It focuses on the most financially stable companies with the best dividend histories.

ETF Profile Overview

• Full Name: Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF
• Core Strategy: Tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index.
• Current Dividend Yield Range: Typically between 3.0% - 3.8%.
• Expense Ratio: 0.06% (extremely low).
• Payout Frequency: Quarterly.
• Main Holding Sectors: Financials, industrials, healthcare, consumer staples.

SCHD’s stock selection strategy is very strict, aiming to screen for true high-quality blue-chip stocks. The index it tracks follows these steps:

1. Initial Screening: First, it looks for companies that have paid dividends continuously for at least 10 years and excludes REITs.
2. Composite Scoring: Then, it scores stocks based on four key financial metrics, including cash flow to total debt ratio, return on equity (ROE), dividend yield, and five-year dividend growth rate.
3. Index Inclusion: Finally, only the top 100 scoring companies are included.
4. Weight Allocation: Companies in the index are weighted by market cap.

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Strict screening ensures high quality and financial health of holdings. History shows that SCHD not only provides stable dividends but also has strong share price growth potential. Data indicates that holding SCHD over the past decade with dividend reinvestment (DRIP) achieved a compound annual growth rate of 11.8%, with total returns 20% higher than without reinvestment.
• Cons: Due to strict criteria, holdings are highly concentrated in mature value companies, potentially lagging broad indices in tech-led bull markets in the short term.

VYM: The Steady Giant with Low Fees

If you want to invest broadly in high-dividend stocks at the lowest cost, Vanguard’s VYM is an excellent choice. It acts like a steady giant, providing broad market coverage and extremely low holding costs.

ETF Profile Overview

• Full Name: Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF
• Core Strategy: Tracks the FTSE High Dividend Yield Index.
• Current Dividend Yield Range: Typically between 2.5% - 3.2%.
• Expense Ratio: 0.06% (extremely low).
• Payout Frequency: Quarterly.
• Main Holding Sectors: Financials, healthcare, consumer staples, energy.

VYM’s strategy is relatively simple and direct. The index it tracks screens for companies in the top half of the US market by dividend yield, resulting in far more holdings than SCHD, usually over 400. This broad diversification contrasts sharply with SCHD’s “select elite” approach.

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Extremely low expense ratio and broad holdings provide high risk diversification. For investors seeking reliability without excessive concentration, VYM offers a simple and efficient solution.
• Cons: VYM’s selection criteria are less strict than SCHD’s, focusing only on high yield without deeply assessing financial health or dividend growth history. This may include some “value trap” companies with limited growth potential.

JEPI: Pursuing High Monthly Cash Flow

For investors prioritizing cash flow, especially retirees, JEPI is a highly attractive option. It uses a special strategy to provide monthly dividends far exceeding the market average.

ETF Profile Overview

• Full Name: JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF
• Core Strategy: Actively managed, combining low-volatility stock holdings with a covered call strategy.
• Current Dividend Yield Range: Historically 6% - 10% or even higher.
• Expense Ratio: 0.35% (relatively low for active management).
• Payout Frequency: Monthly.
• Main Holding Sectors: Industrials, healthcare, financials, tech.

JEPI’s income comes from two parts: one from dividends of its held high-quality large-cap stocks; the other, and more important, from selling “covered calls.” Simply put, the fund manager sells the right to buy stocks at a specific future price, collecting premiums in advance. These premiums form the main source of JEPI’s high monthly dividends. Additionally, it invests part of its assets in equity-linked notes (ELNs) to package these option positions.

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Provides very substantial monthly cash flow, far exceeding traditional dividend ETFs. In sideways or slightly declining markets, the options strategy continues generating income, performing relatively resiliently.
• Cons: The biggest drawback is sacrificing share price upside potential. Selling calls sets a “ceiling” on price gains. In strong bull markets, JEPI’s total returns lag far behind the S&P 500. Its yield is also heavily influenced by market volatility and interest rates.

Additional Note If you are interested in high-yield products in specific sectors, consider PGX (preferred stock ETF) or KBWD (financial high-dividend ETF). They offer income sources different from common stocks but with varying risk profiles.

DGRO: Focusing on Sustained Dividend Growth

If you are a young investor or have a longer investment horizon, DGRO may be a better choice than traditional high-dividend ETFs. It values not just current yield but the ability for “sustained growth” in dividends.

ETF Profile Overview

• Full Name: iShares Core Dividend Growth ETF
• Core Strategy: Tracks the Morningstar US Dividend Growth Index, screening companies with at least 5 consecutive years of dividend growth.
• Current Dividend Yield Range: Typically between 2.2% - 2.6%.
• Expense Ratio: 0.08% (low).
• Payout Frequency: Quarterly.
• Main Holding Sectors: Healthcare, financials, tech, industrials.

DGRO’s investment philosophy is that companies able to raise dividends year after year typically have strong business models and healthy cash flows. It seeks future “dividend aristocrats” rather than just current high-yield stocks. Thus, its yield may not be the highest, but total return potential is significant.

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Balances dividend income and capital appreciation. Investing in such companies allows you to enjoy growing cash flow while sharing in company growth-driven price gains, ideal for long-term investing.
• Cons: Relatively low current yield, less attractive for investors needing immediate cash flow. Holdings include tech growth stocks like Microsoft and Apple, leaning more toward “growth” than pure “value.”

DIVO: Active Management with Options Enhancement

DIVO is another ETF using active management and covered calls, seen as a variant of JEPI but with different tactics. It aims to provide monthly income while retaining some price upside potential.

ETF Profile Overview

• Full Name: Amplify CWP Enhanced Dividend Income ETF
• Core Strategy: Actively managed, holding 20-25 high-quality large-cap stocks and tactically applying covered calls on part of the holdings.
• Current Dividend Yield Range: Typically between 4.0% - 5.5%.
• Expense Ratio: 0.55% (for active management).
• Payout Frequency: Monthly.
• Main Holding Sectors: Financials, tech, healthcare, consumer staples.

Unlike JEPI, DIVO’s manager actively selects 20-25 favored blue-chips and applies covered calls to only part (about 30%-60%) of the portfolio. This “tactical” approach seeks balance between generating extra income and retaining upside.

Pros and Cons

• Pros: Provides decent monthly income while theoretically outperforming JEPI in bull markets due to not optioning all holdings. Active selection may yield excess returns.
• Cons: Higher expense ratio. The covered call strategy inherently trades premium income for missed upside. Additionally, active selection success depends heavily on the manager’s skill, a major long-term challenge to beat the market. This US stock ETF has lower historical volatility but also caps return potential.

Side-by-Side Comparison: How to Choose Your High-Dividend ETF

After analyzing each ETF’s features, you may ask: which one suits me best? This section helps you compare horizontally and make the wisest decision.

Key Metrics Overview

For a more intuitive comparison, we summarize the key metrics of these five ETFs in a table. You can quickly understand their core differences.

Choosing Based on Investment Goals

Now, you can select based on your specific needs from these three directions:

• If you pursue the highest monthly cash flow:

  JEPI is your top choice. It provides highly attractive monthly dividends through options, ideal for retirees needing stable income for expenses. DIVO is also a good monthly payout option, retaining more price growth potential than JEPI.

• If you are a young investor pursuing long-term growth:

  DGRO may be your best partner. It focuses on dividend “growth” rather than current levels. DGRO’s tech allocation (17.9%) far exceeds SCHD’s (8.8%), helping it achieve excellent 11.8% annualized returns over the past decade, ideal for decades-long wealth accumulation.

• If you pursue stability, high quality, and low costs:

  SCHD is synonymous with high quality. It focuses on financially healthy, sustainable dividend-paying companies, suitable for investors seeking a balance of “income and growth”. VYM provides the broadest diversification and lowest costs, a reliable core portfolio choice.

Risk and Return Potential Assessment

High yields often come with specific trade-offs. You must be clear about this when choosing.

Take JEPI as an example; its high yield comes from selling call options. The essence is “trading future upside for current cash income.” In strong market rallies, JEPI’s gains are “capped,” with total returns far behind non-option strategies like SCHD. Data shows JEPI’s 5-year annualized return at 9.58%, with volatility at 13.42%.

In contrast, traditional US stock ETFs like SCHD and DGRO have lower current yields but unlimited upside. In market recoveries or bull runs, they better capture growth for higher total returns. Thus, weigh whether you prioritize immediate cash flow or future growth potential.

Risks and Tax Considerations for Investing in US Stock ETFs

Investing in high-dividend ETFs is an effective way to achieve financial goals, but you must understand potential risks and tax issues. This helps make more comprehensive decisions.

Potential Risks from Share Price Volatility

Remember, ETFs are essentially collections of stocks, so prices fluctuate with the market. High-dividend ETFs are not immune to bear markets. However, history shows dividends are far more stable than prices.

During economic recessions, dividends are typically more resilient than prices. Data from 1900 to 2018 shows average price drops of 32% in market declines versus only 0.5% average dividend cuts. Extreme cases occur, like some high-dividend ETFs (e.g., VYM) seeing ~25% annual dividend reductions in the 2008 crisis.

Impact of Interest Rate Environment Changes

Interest rate changes directly affect high-dividend ETFs’ attractiveness. When the Fed hikes rates, returns on low-risk fixed income like Treasuries rise. Some investors may sell dividend stocks for safer bonds, pressuring high-dividend ETF prices.

Interestingly, market behavior is not always theoretical. Since the Fed’s 2022 rate hike cycle, many high-dividend ETFs have outperformed the broad market, as investors flock to stable cash flow assets in uncertainty—a “safe haven” phenomenon.

Key US Stock Dividend Tax Issues

As a non-US resident investor, dividends received are subject to withholding tax. Understanding rules is crucial.

• Standard Rate: The IRS withholds 30% on non-resident dividends.
• Tax Treaties: If your country/region (e.g., UK, Japan, Germany) has a treaty with the US, the rate can drop to 15% or lower.
• Key Document: Submit the W-8BEN form to your broker to enjoy treaty benefits.

Additionally, some ETF distributions may be classified as “qualified interest income (QII),” often tax-exempt, with refunds claimable next year. To conveniently manage USD funds for US stock ETFs and potential refunds, consider digital financial tools like Biyapay to simplify cross-border management.

High-dividend ETFs are powerful “cash cows” in your portfolio, effective tools for passive income. This article analyzes multiple products, but remember there is no absolute “best”—only the one “most suitable” for you.

History shows diversified portfolios with high-dividend assets better control drawdowns in adjustments, typically limiting losses to 15-20%.

Hope this helps review your goals and take the first step toward passive income. Remember, all investments carry risks; decide cautiously.

FAQ

Are high-dividend ETFs suitable for all investors?

Not necessarily. If you pursue rapid capital appreciation or cannot tolerate any price volatility, these ETFs may not suit you. They are better for long-term investors seeking stable cash flow and lower risk.

Do ETF dividends grow every year?

Not guaranteed. Dividend growth depends on holdings’ profitability and policies. ETFs like DGRO screen for growth history, but future growth remains influenced by the economy.

Should I choose monthly or quarterly payouts?

Depends on your cash flow needs. For monthly income to pay bills, monthly payout ETFs (like JEPI) are more convenient. For long-term appreciation, payout frequency is not primary.

Why does the ETF price drop after dividend payout?

This is normal “ex-dividend” adjustment. The ETF’s asset value decreases by the payout amount, so price adjusts accordingly. You are not losing, as that value is paid as cash to your account.